UKOLN AHDS HTML Analysis Of JISC 5/99 Project Entry Points Update (May 2003)



A follow up survey of the HTML compliance of the home pages of JISC 5/99 projects has been carried out (May 2003). The previous survey carried out in October 2002 is also available at: http://www.ukoln.ac.uk/qa-focus/surveys/web-10-2002/html/ for comparison.

The survey makes use of the W3C HTML compliance checking tool.

You can use the service yourself either by going to the HTML Validator or by entering a URL in the following box:

An extra check has also been added to the survey and makes use of the Web Design Group HTML compliance checking tool. The recursive validator will check up to 100 pages on a Web site.

You can use the service yourself by going to the Web Design Group Validator.

Findings

A summary of the findings is given in the following table. The data was taken from the listing of QA Focus Projects database(no longer available).

Note: Comp? is short for Compliant?

Table 1: Access to Teaching and Learning Resources
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
1 ANGEL Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors  Check - Recursive
2 FAILTE Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors Check - Recursive
3 ICONEX N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors Check - Recursive
4 RESULTs Network N Not specified No document type declaration   Error retrieving - forbidden by robots.txt Check - Recursive

 

Table 2: Enhancing JISC data services for Teaching and Learning
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
5 Biz/ed Virtual Learning Arcade Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors and error retrieving - forbidden by robots.txt Check - Recursive
6 CHCC Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors - 23 pages checked Check - Recursive
7 Enhancing Beilstein CrossFire N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 2 pages checked Check - Recursive
8 e-MapScholar N HTML 4 Several errors   Numerous errors - 64 pages checked - some pages not retrieved Check - Recursive
9 Geo-Crosswalk Gazetteer       No Web site    
8 Go-Geo!: The Geo- data Portal Project N XHTML 1 Several errors   Numerous errors - 1 page checked Check - Recursive
11 Timeweb N HTML 4.01 4 errors   Numerous errors - 3 pages checked Check - Recursive
12 Using Numerical Data N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 3: Images
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
13 ARTWORLD N HTML 4.01 Several errors   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
14 BIOMED N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
15 BuilDNER       No Web site    
16 Crafts Study Centre N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 65 pages checked Check - Recursive
17 Designing Britain 1945-1975 N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 65 pages checked Check - Recursive
18 Filter N HTML 4 2 errors   Numerous errors - 7 pages checked Check - Recursive
19 PICTIVA N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 2 pages checked Check - Recursive
20 Textile Images       No Web site    

 

Table 4: Moving Image and Sound
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
21 Click and Go Video N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
22 HOTBED       No Web site    
23 LIFESIGN N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors -1 page checked Check - Recursive
24 TRILT N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 13 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 5: Museum Content
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
25 Rhynie Chert N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 93 pages checked Check - Recursive
26 Digital Egypt for Universities N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 1 page checked Check - Recursive
27 LEMUR N HTML 3.2 Many errors   Numerous errors - 7 pages checked Check - Recursive
28 MIRACLE N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 14 pages checked Check - Recursive
29 PATOIS Y HTML 4.01     Error retrieving - forbidden by robots.txt Check - Recursive
30 Virtual Norfolk Project N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 6: Miscellaneous
  Project Comp? HTML Version Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
31 EBONI N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
32 INHALE N HTML 4 Many errors   Numerous errors - 98 pages checked Check - Recursive
33 PELICAN N Not specified No document type declaration Converted from MS Word document Numerous errors - 16 pages checked Check - Recursive
34 VDML N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 80 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 7: Infrastructure projects - JOIN-UP
  Project Comp? HTML Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
35 Docusend N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
36 Xgrain N HTML 4 2 errors   Numerous errors - 69 pages checked Check - Recursive
37 ZBLSA N XHTML 1 6 errors   Numerous errors - 29 pages checked Check - Recursive
38 ZETOC Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 8: RDN projects
  Project Comp? HTML Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
39 British Education Portal N No character encoding labeling     Numerous errors - 1 page checked Check - Recursive
40 Computing Gateway N HTML 4 3 errors   Numerous errors - 80 pages checked Check - Recursive
41 Euro Subject Portal for the RDN       No Web site    
42 History online for learning and teaching N HTML 4 4 errors   Numerous errors - 80 pages checked Check - Recursive
43 Maths Portal       No Web site    
44 NMAP N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
45 Physical Sciences Subject Portal for the RDN       No Web site    
46 RDN Virtual Training Suite N HTML 4 5 errors   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
47 SAD-I Y HTML 4.01     Numerous errors -26 pages checked Check - Recursive
48 SPP N XHTML 1.0 10 Errors   Numerous errors - 26 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 9: Z projects
  Project Comp? HTML Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
49 Gate-Z N Not specified No character encoding labeling   Numerous errors - 6 pages checked Check - Recursive
50 JAFER Y XHTML 1.0     Numerous errors - Error retrieving some pages - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive
51 MIMAS Metadata for the DNER Y XHTML 1     Numerous errors - Error retrieving some pages - 67 pages checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 10: Evaluation projects
  Project Comp? HTML Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
52 EDNER N XHTML 1 1 error   1 error - 1 page checked Check - Recursive

 

Table 11: Studies
  Project Comp? HTML Errors CommentsRecursive Try It
53 INSPIRAL N Not specified No document type declaration   Numerous errors - 100 pages checked Check - Recursive

The information in the table was collected on 28th May 2003.

Notes

Please note the following:

Summary

A summary of the findings is given below.

Table 1A: Compliance
Compliant 9 20%
Not Compliant 37 80%
Table 1B: HTML Type
HTML 3.2 1 2%
HTML 4 11 24%
XHTML 1 11 24%
DTD Not Specified 23 50%

Seven projects had no Web site.

The number of compliant 5/99 project entry points has remained the same but the actual projects compliant has changed. Note that more sites now have Web sites - previously 9 were without a site, now seven are without a site. More sites have less error messages.

The number of sites without a DTD remains the same, which is disapointing, but more sites are now using XHTML 1 which is encouraging.

A summary in graphical format is given below.

Histogram of HTML types

Pie chart of HTML compliance